Skip to main content

I don't give grades; students earn them

As I sit here with five folders in front of me, facing the afternoon's work, I am struggling as usual with how to assess the work of each student. Because I teach small classes, I know each student fairly well; that's good, and that's bad. If I could give a good multiple choice test for writing, have a standard correction sheet, and grade accordingly, they would each feel they were treated fairly. In writing, however, it's different.

Each student begins the semester with their own level of expertise. For some , the work in my class challenges that level; for some, it's a breeze. The B that one student struggles for is the one another student earns with no work at all. I try to challenge good students and grade with some knowledge of each student's abilities, but it still becomes a chore at the end of the semester.

And there's the expectations. They got As and Bs in high school--why not in college? Why are commas important here when they weren't in high school? "What do you mean my sentences don't flow?" "I DID look this up on balancedpolitics.org" (which is, of course, not balanced). "What do you mean this doesn't make sense. My Mom said it was good!"

So I am struggling. Pray for me.

Mrs. B

Comments

Popular posts from this blog

Wanted: 850 new FBI agents

My dream job is finally available. FBI, here I come! When I logged on to CNN today and found that the FBI is hiring, ( cnn.com/2009/CRIME/01/05/fbi.hiring.binge/index.html ) my heart tripped the tango. I've always wanted to follow in the steps of one of my literary heroes, Mrs. Pollifax, the delightful grandmotherly woman who gets assignments that take her all over the world as a courier and spy. Ooops. Wait, it's the CIA that sends people all over the world. The FBI handles problems in the U.S. Okay, I can still live with that. Apparently this is the largest job posting for FBI agents since 2001, and it includes openings for more than 2,000 support personnel as well. I wonder if the FBI is trying to hire some of the financial folks and automakers who got pink-slipped at the end of 2008? Or is bail-out money going to the FBI? When most employers--including state governments--are letting people go, where does the FBI get money for new hires? The lengthy list of openings includes...

What's Next for 2009: Predictions and Educated Guesses

There's an old saying that the year will go the way the stock market goes for the first week of January. I hope that's true, because today's market went above 9,000 for the first time since November. Any ray of sunshine helps! I was delighted to say goodbye to 2008, which was a tough year all the way around. While I dealt with the death of friends and family and a job change, many Americans faced mortgage foreclosures, job losses, and economic failure. I count myself lucky to be employed, and I am especially looking forward to my first grandchild in 2009. So other than a grandchild, what do I think 2009 will bring? Here are my predictions and educated guesses: 1. Barack Obama will show us that he has more good sense, common sense, and downright intelligence than any president since Franklin Roosevelt. He has already demonstrated this by choosing cabinet-level staff that are experienced and educated in their areas and willing to work together. With a "can do" staff...

A book that makes me think

Every once in a while I read a book that I'd like to put on a reading list for every American. This time it's Susan Jacoby's The Age of American Unreason. It's clear from Jacoby's writing and her content that she is an American intellectual of the highest order. To get the full meaning of her prose, I found myself re-reading paragraphs, asking myself if I agree with her ideas, reviewing the framework she uses to make her points, and looking at her bibliography to assess her sources. From her bibliography, I've found at least three more books I want to read. What is her point? Jacoby believes that America has settled into an age of anti-rationalism and anti-intellectualism, as evidenced by the huge numbers of Americans who do not know--or never learned--the basics of science, the primary events of American history, and critical reading skills. Her point is that Americans believe what they are told without giving thought to who is speaking or writing, and that we ...